Pie in Red Herring
Pie has appeared on 27 boards: 18 times inside a themed group and 9 times as a red herring. That is a 33% decoy rate.
Is Pie a Red Herring?
Every appearance of Pie across the 3,529-board archive, and whether it belonged to a group that day or to the herrings.
Groups it has belonged to
Pie on 27 Boards
Newest first. Red panels are the boards where it was a decoy — those are the ones worth remembering.
What the Puzzle Said About Pie
November 22, 2018
Scottish economist William Playfair (1759-1823) was the first to publish (and appears to have invented) pie, bar, line, and area charts.
July 5, 2021
Scottish economist William Playfair (1759-1823) was the first to publish (and appears to have invented) pie, bar, line, and area charts.
February 16, 2024
Scottish economist William Playfair (1759-1823) was the first to publish (and appears to have invented) pie, bar, line, and area charts.
October 11, 2025
Rhubarb is sometimes called "pieplant," a reference to its primary use.
Using a Word's History Without Being Fooled By It
A high decoy rate is a warning, not a rule
Pie has been a red herring on 33% of its appearances. That makes it worth leaving until last, not worth discarding — the board decides, and the three-group structure is what settles it.
Themes repeat, words move between them
This word has sat in 7 different themes. A returning theme brings different members with it, which is why the category pages show every word a theme has ever used rather than a fixed four.
Count to sixteen first
Three groups of four plus four herrings. Four words are meant to be left over, and expecting that is what stops you forcing a fourth group that was never there.
How to Solve a Red Herring Board
The order that clears a board fastest.
Count to sixteen first
Three groups of four plus four red herrings. Four words are meant to be left over — see any board in the archive.
Lock the tightest theme
Solve the most specific group first; each correct group removes four candidates from everything else.
Distrust the near-miss
A word that almost fits two groups is usually a decoy — which is exactly what a page like this one records.
Verified Answers, Not Guesses
How we verify every board Pie has appeared on, and whether it was an answer or a decoy each time
Word histories are built from the 3,529 dated boards in our archive rather than from any published list — the source has no word pages. Each appearance links to the board it came from so it can be checked. The routine is in our methodology and the standards in our editorial policy.
Reviewed by Priya Raghunathan, Word Games Editor at Puzzle Solved. The full checking routine is in the methodology, and the standards every page is held to are in the editorial policy.
Last checked — Aug 24, 2026